Stop scary ads for horror movies displayed where children have every right to be
Horror movies are being promoted in public spaces such as main road billboards, bus shelters, on the sides of public transport, boundary screens at sporting events, and via trailers on free-to air TV.
The scary images used are causing children much distress, and can cause ongoing harm. Their parents are rightly complaining that they cannot protect their children from such images, and sometimes the ongoing issues for their children are difficult and expensive to try to rectify.
Child psychologists tell us that the distress is real, and so are the consequences. See more on this below.
ACCM has campaigned about these images for many years. See “Stop ambushing parents with unsuitable trailers” https://childrenandmedia.org.au/taking-action/current-campaigns/stop-ambushing-parents-with-unsuitable-trailers
It’s time the industry changed its behaviour to protect children who are in public spaces where they have every right to be.
What's happened recently
Over the past few years, many parents have lodged complaints with the Advertising Standards Bureau, https://adstandards.com.au/codes-and-cases about the images used to promote horror movies such as Halloween, It, Pet Semetary, Us, and Annabelle comes home. In many cases these complaints have not been upheld as they haven’t breached the Australian Association of National Advertiser’s (AANA) Code of Ethics. Two defects in the Code have contributed to this: firstly, para 2.3 appears to act as a let-out for violent images used to promote violent films, and secondly, there is no code which deals with scary images. (The AANA Code for advertising and marketing communications directed to children which does have such a prohibition does not apply to such advertising).
Recent advertisements on billboards and in bus shelters for horror movie It: Chapter two have caused a new public outcry.
And now the AANA has announced a review of its Code of Ethics. https://aana.com.au/content/uploads/2019/09/AANA-Code-of-Ethics-Review-Discussion-Paper-September-2019.pdf Submissions are due by October 18.
What needs to happen
The AANA needs to be persuaded to change some of the provisions in its Code of Ethics.
For example, para 2.3 which says that
Advertising or Marketing Communication shall not present or portray violence unless it is justifiable in the context of the product or service advertised.
should not be used to excuse the use of violent images to promote violent movies.
And it’s time to insert a prohibition against advertising in public spaces, that uses” images or events in a way that is unduly frightening or distressing to Children” ( which appears under the heading of “Social values”, in Para 2.6 of the Code for advertising and marketing communication to children.) And drop the very subjective “unduly” while we’re at it.
What should also happen, is that FreeTV Australia’s Clearads division should revise its classification processes for TV trailers (advertising) for violent and horror movies.
What's happened recently?
Submissions were due by October 18. This deadline has been extended. Contact the AANA if you want to lodge a submission.
What you can do
- Send us examples of advertising that has scared your children
- Support ACCM’s GoFundme campaign [link]to raise funds to support an effective campaign to fix these longstanding problems.
- Write a submission to the AANA about your views about scary ads by October 18
- Spread the word about the AANA review.
NOTE: more about scary ads
Dr Lesley-Anne Ey has this to say about ads for It: Chapter two
“The impacts of exposing young children to such promotions are not trivial. Ongoing issues from exposure to scary images can include continuous nightmares, bed-wetting and fatigue due to lack of or interrupted sleep, which can interrupt children’s education and daily life.
Scary images such as the It poster are more likely than not, going to give many children nightmares, particularly young children.
The stark white face, the portrayal of blood or gashes going from It’s forehead down his cheeks to his mouth, the portrayal of blood dripping from It’s large mouth and the jagged teeth is a terrifying image for children.
When children are exposed to an image that does not fit within their schemes of what they know, in this case what a clown should look like, they tend to look more closely to try to make sense of the image. They then absorb more detail and the image becomes entrenched in their minds.
If you are familiar with the concept that ‘once you see something, you can’t un-see it’, it is not difficult to understand why children who have been distressed by this image will continue picturing the image in their head and of course, they are more vulnerable to picturing this image at bed time when they are not distracted by other things, leading to a fear of going to bed, a fear of not wanting to be alone and nightmares.
Research demonstrates that children from the age of 6 years old can retain images equivalent to the retention of college students. If children have been unfortunate enough to see the trailer, that contains very scary and gruesome images they are likely to play back the trailer in their mind.
Children can develop ‘Coulrophobia’ [fear of clowns] , which can have life-long impacts. Such images should not be in public places where children can see them.
Dr Lesley-Anne Ey, Lecturer, School of Education, Magill campus, University of South Australia